Roymech engineering encyclopedia

Machine Element Selection Guide


Machine elements are selected primarily by the function that the machine must perform. The designer may need to convert one type of motion into another, store or absorb energy, generate a large linear force, control a repeated motion, or connect several components into a mechanism.

This guide provides a practical route into the RoyMech references for cams, flywheels, power screws and shock absorbers, together with the larger springs and mechanisms sections.

Already know which component you need? Go directly to the relevant RoyMech technical reference. This guide is intended mainly to help when choosing between different machine elements or deciding which calculation route to use.

Start with the Required Function

Required Function Consider RoyMech Reference
Produce a prescribed repeated displacement from a rotating input Cam and follower Cams and Followers
Store rotational energy or reduce cyclic speed variation Flywheel Flywheels
Convert rotary motion into controlled linear motion or generate a large axial force Power screw, ball screw or roller screw Power Screws
Reduce impact force or dissipate the energy of a moving load Shock absorber, buffer or damping system Shock Absorbers
Store elastic energy, provide a restoring force or maintain contact between components Spring Springs
Transform, constrain, reverse, index or otherwise control mechanical motion Mechanism or linkage Mechanisms

Choosing Between the Main Machine Elements

Cams and Followers

Use a cam when rotation must produce a deliberately shaped and repeatable follower motion. The cam profile determines how displacement varies throughout the operating cycle.

Typical requirements include rise, dwell and return motions in machinery where a specific displacement programme must repeat every revolution or cycle.

Cams and Followers

Flywheels

Use a flywheel when energy must be stored in a rotating mass and released as the machine passes through portions of its operating cycle where the driving torque and load torque do not balance.

Flywheel design is concerned with rotational energy, moment of inertia, permissible speed fluctuation and stresses produced by rotation.

Flywheel Design

Power Screws

Use a power screw when rotary motion must produce linear movement or a large axial force. Typical applications include screw jacks, presses, clamps, lead screws and linear actuators.

Sliding-thread screws can provide high mechanical advantage and may be self-locking under suitable conditions. Ball and roller screws provide much lower friction and higher efficiency where speed, duty or positioning performance is important.

Power Screw Selection

Shock Absorbers

Use a shock absorber or energy absorber when a moving load must be brought to rest without producing the very high forces associated with stopping it over a very short distance.

Selection is based primarily on the energy per impact, impact velocity, available stroke and any additional force or torque that continues to supply energy during the stopping movement.

Shock Absorber Calculations

When Do I Need a Spring?

A spring is appropriate when the required function involves elastic deflection and a restoring force. Springs can store energy, maintain contact, apply a preload, return components to a known position, accommodate movement or isolate vibration.

The choice is not simply between a spring and no spring. Different spring forms suit different combinations of force, displacement, available space, fatigue duty and stiffness.

Examples include:

  • Compression springs for an axial force that increases with compression.
  • Extension springs where a tensile restoring force is required.
  • Torsion springs where torque is required through angular displacement.
  • Disc springs where high forces are required within a relatively small axial space.
  • Leaf springs where the spring itself may also locate or guide the supported component.
Need to choose a spring? See the Spring Selection and Design Guide for guidance on spring type, loading, stiffness, stress, fatigue and selecting the appropriate RoyMech spring reference.

When Do I Need a Mechanism?

A mechanism is used when the requirement is better described as a motion transformation or sequence than as the behaviour of one individual machine element.

Mechanisms can convert, constrain, reverse, interrupt or sequence motion. The most appropriate arrangement depends on the required input and output motions, available space, load, speed, accuracy, dwell requirements and whether the motion must be continuous or intermittent.

Typical examples include:

  • Snap-action and toggle mechanisms.
  • Linear actuators.
  • Fine-adjustment mechanisms.
  • Clamping and locating mechanisms.
  • Ratchets and one-way motion systems.
  • Escapements.
  • Indexing mechanisms.
  • Rocking and oscillating mechanisms.
  • Reciprocating mechanisms.
  • Reversing mechanisms.
  • Couplings and connectors.
  • Stop and dwell mechanisms.
  • Curve and straight-line generators.
  • Pantographs and tracing mechanisms.

The RoyMech Mechanisms section provides an overview of these functional groups and links to the more detailed mechanism references.

Mechanisms Reference

Cam, Linkage or Controlled Actuator?

Several different machine elements can sometimes achieve the same nominal movement. The choice depends on what matters most in the application.

Requirement Possible Approach Important Considerations
Fixed repeated motion tied directly to shaft rotation Cam Follower motion, pressure angle, acceleration, contact loading and wear
Motion determined geometrically by connected rigid members Linkage Geometry, range of movement, transmission angle, joints and clearances
Linear movement with large mechanical advantage Power screw Torque, efficiency, friction, strength, speed and self-locking
Motion profile must be readily changed during operation or between products Servo-controlled electric, hydraulic or pneumatic actuator Control system, feedback, actuator capacity, speed and dynamic response

Mechanical mechanisms remain particularly useful where a fixed relationship between input and output motion is required repeatedly and reliably. Controlled actuators become attractive when the motion programme must be changed without changing the mechanical geometry.

Spring or Shock Absorber?

Springs and shock absorbers are often used together, but they perform different fundamental functions.

Requirement Spring Shock Absorber / Damper
Store mechanical energy Yes Normally no – energy is primarily dissipated
Provide restoring force Yes Not its primary function
Dissipate impact energy Limited unless damping is present Yes
Reduce rebound Not by itself Yes, when appropriately selected
Control vibration Provides stiffness Provides damping

A spring can reduce impact force by increasing stopping distance, but it stores the absorbed energy and can subsequently return it to the moving mass. A damper dissipates energy and is therefore used where rebound and oscillation must be controlled. Many practical systems use both.

Sliding Power Screw or Ball Screw?

The choice between a conventional sliding-thread power screw and a ball screw is often determined by the balance between mechanical advantage, efficiency, positioning performance and resistance to back-driving.

Requirement Consider
Simple, robust high-force mechanism Square, Acme or buttress power screw depending on the loading arrangement
Split-nut arrangement Acme thread
Heavy load predominantly in one axial direction Buttress thread
High efficiency Ball screw or roller screw
High-speed precision positioning Ball screw
High load and high stiffness in a compact rolling-screw arrangement Roller screw
Load must resist back-driving Check sliding-screw self-locking conditions or provide a separate brake/locking system
Safety: Do not rely on an assumed self-locking screw characteristic where uncontrolled movement could endanger people or equipment. Verify the actual screw geometry and friction and provide an appropriate independent holding or braking system where required.

Which Power Screw Calculation Do I Need?

Torque, Efficiency and Self-Locking

Use this reference when you need the torque required to raise or lower a load, screw efficiency, the effect of thread and collar friction, or whether a sliding screw is self-locking or capable of overhauling.

Torque & Efficiency Equations

Strength and Buckling

Use this reference to assess thread bearing, bending and shear stress, direct axial stress, combined axial and torsional loading, or possible column buckling of a long compression-loaded screw.

Strength Equations

Machine Element Selection Checklist

Before choosing a component or mechanism, define the engineering requirement rather than beginning with a preferred solution.

1. Motion What are the required input and output motions: rotary, linear, reciprocating, oscillating or intermittent?
2. Force and Torque What forces and torques must be transmitted, resisted or generated?
3. Energy Must energy be stored, released, dissipated or transferred?
4. Speed What are the operating speed, acceleration and cycle rate?
5. Accuracy What positioning accuracy, repeatability and backlash are acceptable?
6. Duty Is the operation occasional, intermittent or continuous?
7. Environment Consider temperature, lubrication, contamination, corrosion and maintenance access.
8. Life Consider wear, fatigue, impact loading and the required service life.
9. Failure Behaviour What happens if the component wears, jams, back-drives, breaks or reaches the end of its travel?
10. Safety Determine whether independent stops, brakes, guards, overload protection or redundant load support are required.

RoyMech Machine Element References

Cams

Cam types, follower arrangements, displacement diagrams and motion relationships.

Cams

Flywheels

Rotational energy storage, inertia, speed fluctuation and rotating stresses.

Flywheels

Power Screws

Thread forms, ball and roller screws, torque, efficiency, strength and buckling.

Power Screws

Shock Absorbers

Impact energy, stopping force and absorber duty calculations for moving loads.

Shock Absorbers

Springs

The larger RoyMech spring section covering spring types, design calculations and engineering data.

Springs

Mechanisms

Motion-control mechanisms including clamps, ratchets, indexing, reciprocating and rocking mechanisms, couplings and motion generators.

Mechanisms


�