Roymech engineering encyclopedia

Fatigue Loading and Mean Stress in Engineering


Fatigue loading describes the repeated or fluctuating stresses that can lead to fatigue damage and eventual failure of an engineering component. The relationship between the maximum stress, minimum stress, mean stress and stress amplitude is important when assessing fatigue life.

Common fatigue loading conditions include fully reversed alternating stress, repeated stress, and cyclic stress superimposed on a steady mean stress. This page explains these loading types and introduces the Soderberg, Goodman and Gerber criteria used when considering the combined effects of mean and alternating stress.

Fatigue Loading Types

The fatigue action or loading type describes how the stress in a component changes during repeated loading. The maximum and minimum stresses in each cycle determine the mean stress, stress amplitude and stress ratio.

Alternating or Fully Reversed Stress

In determining fatigue stress levels using standard test equipment, test specimens may be subjected to fully reversed stress. The cyclic stress varies from a tensile stress σa to an equal compressive stress -σa. The mean stress is therefore zero.

Fully reversed alternating fatigue stress cycle

Fatigue strength values for metals are commonly determined using this type of loading. The published fatigue strength S'n represents the material fatigue strength at the specified number of stress cycles under the stated test conditions.

Repeated Stress

In repeated stress loading, the stress varies cyclically between zero and a maximum tensile stress, or between zero and a maximum compressive stress.

Repeated fatigue stress varying between zero and maximum stress

Combined Steady and Cyclic Stress

A loading condition commonly experienced in engineering practice consists of a cyclic stress superimposed on a steady mean stress. In this case the stress varies between a maximum and minimum value about a non-zero mean stress.

Combined alternating fatigue stress with non-zero mean stress

Fatigue Stress Terms

The following quantities are used to describe a fatigue stress cycle:

  • Maximum stress: σmax
  • Minimum stress: σmin
  • Mean stress: σmean = (σmax + σmin) / 2
  • Stress amplitude: σamp = (σmax - σmin) / 2
  • Stress ratio: R = σmin / σmax

For a fully reversed alternating stress: R = -1.

For repeated tensile loading between zero and a maximum tensile stress: R = 0.

The stress ratio is useful because it provides a simple way of describing the relationship between the minimum and maximum stresses in a fatigue loading cycle.

Combined Mean Stress and Alternating Stress

Mean stress can have a significant effect on fatigue performance and should therefore be considered together with the alternating stress. A tensile mean stress will generally reduce the allowable alternating stress compared with fully reversed loading.

A number of interaction criteria are commonly used to represent the relationship between mean stress and alternating stress. The Soderberg, Goodman and Gerber criteria are illustrated below.

Soderberg Goodman and Gerber fatigue mean stress diagram

The mean stress σmean is plotted on the horizontal axis and the alternating stress σamp is plotted on the vertical axis.

Soderberg Line

The Soderberg criterion provides a conservative relationship between alternating stress and mean stress and is based on the material yield strength Syt. A design operating point below the Soderberg line is within the allowable region according to this criterion.

The following relationship may be used to establish the factor of safety relative to the Soderberg criterion:

Soderberg fatigue factor of safety equation

(Kf σamp / Se) + (σmean / Syt) = 1 / Nf

Goodman Line / Modified Goodman Line

The Goodman criterion relates alternating stress to mean stress using the material ultimate tensile strength Sut. It is less conservative than the Soderberg criterion for many common fatigue design situations.

A design operating point below the relevant Goodman line is within the allowable region according to this criterion.

The following relationship may be used to establish the factor of safety relative to the Goodman criterion:

Goodman fatigue factor of safety equation

(Kf σamp / Se) + (σmean / Sut) = 1 / Nf

Gerber Line

The Gerber criterion represents the relationship between alternating and mean stress using a parabolic curve based on the material ultimate tensile strength Sut. It generally permits a higher alternating stress than the Soderberg or modified Goodman criteria for the same tensile mean stress.

A design operating point below the Gerber curve is within the allowable region according to this criterion.

The following relationship may be used to establish the factor of safety relative to the Gerber criterion:

Gerber fatigue factor of safety equation

(Nf Kf σamp / Se) + (Nf σmean / Sut)2 = 1

Fatigue Diagram Terms

  • Se = Modified fatigue strength or endurance limit
  • Sut = Ultimate tensile strength
  • Syt = Yield tensile strength
  • Nf = Factor of safety applicable to fatigue

Using the Mean Stress Diagram

For a preliminary fatigue assessment, first determine the maximum and minimum stress during the loading cycle. These values can then be used to calculate the mean stress and alternating stress amplitude.

  1. Determine σmax and σmin for the stress cycle.
  2. Calculate the mean stress σmean = (σmax + σmin) / 2.
  3. Calculate the alternating stress amplitude σamp = (σmax - σmin) / 2.
  4. Plot or compare the resulting combination of mean and alternating stress against the selected Soderberg, Goodman or Gerber criterion.
  5. Apply the appropriate fatigue strength, modifying factors, stress concentration factors and design factor of safety for the component.

Fatigue Loading FAQs

What are the main types of fatigue loading?

Common fatigue loading conditions include fully reversed alternating stress, repeated stress and cyclic stress superimposed on a steady mean stress. The loading condition determines the maximum stress, minimum stress, mean stress and stress amplitude experienced by the component.

What is fully reversed fatigue loading?

In fully reversed fatigue loading, the stress varies between equal tensile and compressive values. The mean stress is zero and the stress ratio R is -1.

What is stress amplitude in fatigue?

The stress amplitude is half the difference between the maximum and minimum stresses in a fatigue cycle: σamp = (σmax - σmin) / 2.

What is mean stress in fatigue?

Mean stress is the average of the maximum and minimum stresses during a loading cycle: σmean = (σmax + σmin) / 2. Mean stress can significantly affect the fatigue performance of a component.

What is the fatigue stress ratio R?

The fatigue stress ratio is defined as R = σmin / σmax. For fully reversed loading R = -1, while repeated tensile loading between zero and the maximum tensile stress has R = 0.

What is the difference between Soderberg, Goodman and Gerber fatigue criteria?

Soderberg, Goodman and Gerber are methods of relating alternating stress to mean stress in fatigue assessment. The Soderberg criterion uses yield strength and is generally the most conservative. The Goodman criterion uses ultimate tensile strength, while the Gerber criterion uses a parabolic relationship based on ultimate tensile strength.

Why does mean stress matter in fatigue design?

A non-zero mean stress changes the fatigue loading condition. In particular, a tensile mean stress will generally reduce the allowable alternating stress compared with fully reversed loading, so both mean stress and stress amplitude should be considered during fatigue assessment.

Related Fatigue Engineering Resources



Useful Links
  1. eFatigue.com — Source of fatigue information and data, primarily based on US materials.