Roymech engineering encyclopedia

Spring Selection and Design Guide


Springs are used throughout mechanical engineering to store energy, apply forces or torques, absorb movement and shock, maintain contact between components, and return mechanisms to a required position.

Choosing a spring is not simply a matter of finding one that fits the available space. The engineer must consider the required force or torque, movement, spring rate, available envelope, operating life, material, temperature, fatigue, stability and, in rapidly operating machinery, dynamic behaviour.

This guide introduces the main spring types and the engineering decisions involved in selecting and designing them. Links throughout the page lead to the detailed RoyMech reference pages containing the equations and design data.

New to spring design?
Start with the required load and movement, then choose the spring arrangement that naturally produces that type of motion. Do not begin by selecting a wire diameter or spring size.

Contents

1. What Does the Spring Need to Do?

Before choosing a spring type, define what the spring must achieve in the mechanism.

Typical spring functions include:

  • Applying a force — for example maintaining contact, closing a valve or clamping a component.
  • Returning a mechanism — moving a component back to its original position after the operating force is removed.
  • Applying a torque — rotating a lever, hinge, shaft or other component.
  • Storing energy — energy supplied during loading is stored as elastic strain energy and subsequently released.
  • Absorbing movement or shock — allowing controlled displacement when a load is applied.
  • Supporting a load — as in suspension and resilient mounting systems.
  • Compensating for dimensional variation — maintaining contact despite wear, tolerance or thermal movement.
First design question:
Is the required spring action primarily linear force or rotary torque? This immediately narrows the choice of spring.

2. Choosing a Spring Type

Compression Springs

A compression spring becomes shorter when loaded and produces a force opposing that compression.

The familiar cylindrical helical compression spring is one of the most widely used spring forms. It is suitable where an approximately axial force is required over a linear movement.

Typical applications include valves, machine mechanisms, vehicle components, tooling, switches and return mechanisms.

Consider a compression spring when: you need an axial force that increases as two components move towards one another.

Detailed calculations: Helical Springs

Extension Springs

An extension or tension spring becomes longer when loaded. Hooks, loops or other end features transmit the tensile load into the spring body.

Unlike an ordinary compression spring, an extension spring may be manufactured with initial tension. This means that a finite force may be required before the coils begin to separate.

Consider an extension spring when: two components must be pulled towards one another or returned together after being separated.

Detailed calculations: Helical Springs

Torsion Springs

A helical torsion spring applies a torque when its legs are rotated relative to one another.

Although it has a helical appearance, the wire in a torsion spring is principally subjected to bending rather than the torsional loading that dominates an axial helical compression spring.

Typical applications include hinges, clips, catches, levers and return mechanisms.

Consider a torsion spring when: the required output is a torque or angular restoring action.

Detailed calculations: Torsion Springs

Disc Springs

Disc springs are conical annular discs that flatten elastically under axial load. They are also commonly called Belleville springs.

A disc spring can produce a relatively large axial force within a small axial space. Individual discs can also be arranged in series, parallel or combined stacks to alter the required force and deflection characteristics.

Consider disc springs when: high axial force is required in a restricted space, or when the load and deflection characteristics can usefully be adjusted by stacking discs.

Detailed calculations: Disc Springs

Leaf Springs

A leaf spring stores energy by bending a strip or assembly of strips. Unlike a helical spring, the spring element itself can also form a structural member of the mechanism.

Leaf springs are strongly associated with vehicle suspension but the same bending-spring principle is used in many mechanisms, electrical contacts, clips and flexible components.

Consider a leaf spring when: a bending member suits the geometry of the mechanism or the spring must also provide structural guidance or support.

Detailed calculations: Leaf Springs

Spiral and Clock Springs

A spiral spring consists of a flat strip wound into a spiral. Rotation changes the curvature of the strip and stores elastic energy.

These springs are useful where energy must be stored or a restoring torque produced through angular movement.

Consider a spiral spring when: rotational movement and energy storage are required in a relatively flat package.

Detailed calculations: Spiral / Clock Springs

Quick Spring Selection Table

Requirement Spring Type to Consider Detailed RoyMech Page
Axial force when compressed Helical compression spring Helical Springs
Pulling or return force in tension Extension spring Helical Springs
Torque through angular movement Helical torsion spring Torsion Springs
High axial load with small axial movement Disc spring Disc Springs
Spring action through bending Leaf spring Leaf Springs
Rotational energy storage Spiral / clock spring Spiral Springs

3. Understanding Spring Rate

One of the most important quantities in spring design is the spring rate, sometimes called spring stiffness.

For a linear spring:

k = F δ

where:

  • k = spring rate
  • F = applied force
  • δ = elastic deflection

For example, a spring having a rate of 20 N/mm requires an additional 20 N of force for each additional millimetre of deflection, provided it is operating within its linear elastic range.

Spring rate is not the same as spring force.
Spring rate describes how rapidly force changes with deflection. The actual spring force depends on how far the spring has been deflected and whether preload or initial tension is present.

Rotational Spring Rate

For a spring producing torque through angular movement, the equivalent relationship is:

k = T θ

where T is torque and θ is angular deflection in radians.

4. Load and Deflection

A useful way to think about any spring is through its load-deflection characteristic.

For an ideal linear spring:

F = k δ

The load-deflection graph is therefore a straight line. Real spring systems may instead have progressive, degressive or otherwise non-linear characteristics.

The area beneath the load-deflection curve represents the elastic energy stored by the spring.

For a linear spring loaded from zero force:

U = 1 2 F δ = 1 2 k δ 2

For more information see General Spring Notes.

5. Preload and Working Range

A spring does not necessarily operate between zero load and its maximum load. Many springs are installed with an initial deflection so that they already exert a force before the mechanism begins its working movement. This is called preload.

Suppose a mechanism requires a spring force of 100 N at one position and 180 N after moving 20 mm. The required working spring rate is:

k = 180 − 100 20 = 4  N/mm

The spring therefore requires a rate of 4 N/mm, but it must already be deflected sufficiently at the first working position to produce the required 100 N preload.

Useful design habit:
Define the required spring force at both ends of the working movement. This usually tells you much more than specifying only a maximum force.

6. Spring Stress

Springs work by allowing controlled elastic deformation of their material. That deformation creates stress.

The important stress depends on the spring type:

  • Helical compression and extension spring wire is primarily subjected to torsional shear stress, with curvature effects requiring appropriate stress correction.
  • Helical torsion springs principally develop bending stress in the wire.
  • Leaf springs develop bending stresses.
  • Disc springs develop a more complex stress distribution that varies through the disc and with its deflection.
  • Spiral springs primarily develop bending stress in the strip.

This is why the stress equation from one type of spring must not simply be applied to another.

A spring fitting into the available space does not mean it is strong enough.
The working stresses must be checked over the complete operating range, including maximum deflection and any preload.

7. Choosing a Spring Material

Spring materials must withstand significant elastic strain without permanent deformation and may also need to survive a very large number of load cycles.

Material selection can depend on:

  • required strength
  • fatigue resistance
  • spring dimensions
  • operating temperature
  • corrosion and environment
  • electrical or magnetic requirements
  • manufacturing and heat-treatment process
  • cost and availability

Carbon and alloy spring steels are widely used, while stainless steels, copper alloys and other materials may be selected where environmental or special operating requirements justify them.

Detailed material information: Spring Materials

8. Fatigue and Spring Life

Many springs operate under repeated fluctuating loads. A spring may therefore fail by fatigue even though its maximum stress is below the stress that would cause immediate yielding.

Two quantities are particularly important when examining a fluctuating spring load:

  • mean stress — the average stress during the cycle
  • alternating stress — the stress amplitude about that mean

Both affect fatigue performance.

Surface condition is particularly important because fatigue cracks commonly initiate at the surface. Manufacturing defects, corrosion, damage and rubbing against guides can therefore reduce spring life.

Processes such as shot peening may be used to improve fatigue performance in appropriate spring applications.

Detailed calculations and fatigue criteria: Fatigue in Springs

9. Compression Spring Buckling

A long compression spring may become laterally unstable as it is compressed. Instead of simply becoming shorter, it begins to bow sideways. This is known as buckling.

Buckling becomes increasingly important as the free length becomes large relative to the spring diameter.

The spring end conditions also matter. A spring restrained between suitable parallel seats behaves differently from one having poorly restrained ends.

Where sufficient inherent stability cannot be achieved, the spring may require:

  • an internal guide rod
  • an external bore or sleeve
  • a shorter or wider spring geometry
  • some other form of lateral restraint

Guidance itself must be designed carefully because rubbing can introduce friction, wear and surface damage.

Detailed buckling calculations: Compression Spring Stability and Buckling

10. Surge and Natural Frequency

Static spring calculations are not always sufficient for rapidly operating mechanisms.

A spring has mass as well as stiffness and therefore possesses natural frequencies. Rapid cyclic loading can cause vibration waves to travel through a helical spring. Under suitable conditions these can form standing waves, a phenomenon known as spring surge.

If an excitation frequency is sufficiently close to a significant natural frequency, resonance can increase spring movement and dynamic stress.

Buckling and surge are different problems.
Buckling is lateral instability of a compressed spring.
Surge is dynamic vibration associated with the spring's natural modes.

Surge should be considered particularly in rapidly reciprocating mechanisms, high-speed machinery and other applications involving significant periodic excitation.

Detailed theory and equations: Spring Surge and Natural Frequency

11. Practical Design Considerations

Available Space

Determine the available outside diameter, inside diameter and axial or radial space before completing the spring design. Remember that the spring geometry can change as it deflects.

Maximum and Minimum Positions

Check the spring throughout its complete travel, not only at its normal operating position.

Manufacturing Tolerances

Real springs cannot be manufactured to exact theoretical dimensions or forces. The mechanism should accommodate the relevant spring and assembly tolerances.

Temperature

Material properties change with temperature. Springs operating at unusually high or low temperatures require suitable material selection and design allowances.

Corrosion

Corrosion can reduce section size and create surface defects that are particularly damaging to fatigue performance. Material, coating and environmental protection should therefore be considered together.

End Connections

The way load enters the spring matters. Compression-spring seats, extension spring hooks and torsion-spring legs can all influence stress, alignment and service life.

Clearance

Check that the spring does not unintentionally contact shafts, bores, adjacent components or itself during its complete working movement.

12. Common Spring Design Mistakes

  • Choosing a spring from its dimensions alone. A spring must satisfy the required force-deflection characteristic as well as fit the available space.
  • Confusing spring rate with spring force. Rate is force change per unit movement; it is not the force at every position.
  • Ignoring preload. Many mechanisms require a useful spring force before any working movement takes place.
  • Checking only maximum force. Both ends of the working range are important when establishing spring rate and preload.
  • Ignoring fatigue. Repeated loading can cause failure below the static yield strength.
  • Ignoring stress concentration or curvature effects. Nominal stress may not represent the maximum local stress in a spring.
  • Ignoring buckling. A long compression spring may be strong enough but still be laterally unstable.
  • Ignoring dynamics. A spring that works perfectly in a slowly operated mechanism may experience surge or resonance at high operating speed.
  • Mixing units. Using N/mm in one equation and N/m in another without conversion can produce errors by factors of 1000 or more.
  • Designing exactly to a limiting condition. Manufacturing tolerances, material variation, temperature, wear and actual operating loads must be considered.

13. A Practical Spring Selection Workflow

Step 1 — Define the Required Motion

Is the movement linear or angular? How far must the mechanism move?

Step 2 — Define the Required Loads

Determine the required force or torque at the beginning and end of the working movement.

Step 3 — Determine the Required Spring Rate

Use the change in force divided by the corresponding change in deflection, or the change in torque divided by angular movement.

Step 4 — Select a Suitable Spring Type

Choose a compression, extension, torsion, disc, leaf or spiral spring based on the required motion, load and available geometry.

Step 5 — Establish the Available Envelope

Determine the maximum and minimum permitted spring dimensions throughout the complete mechanism movement.

Step 6 — Select Material and Preliminary Geometry

Choose a material and initial spring dimensions suitable for the required load, environment, temperature and manufacturing process.

Step 7 — Calculate Stress

Use the detailed equation appropriate to the selected spring type and check the most severe operating condition.

Step 8 — Check Fatigue Where Required

For cyclic applications, determine the mean and alternating stresses and apply an appropriate fatigue assessment.

Step 9 — Check Stability and Dynamics

For compression springs, check buckling where appropriate. For rapidly operated springs, consider natural frequency and surge.

Step 10 — Check the Complete Installation

Review clearances, guides, seats, hooks, tolerances, corrosion protection, temperature and interaction with surrounding components.

Then move to the detailed calculation page.
Once the spring type and design requirements are understood, use the appropriate RoyMech reference page below for the detailed equations, engineering data and design checks.

14. RoyMech Spring Reference Pages

Reference Use It For
General Spring Notes Spring rate, load-deflection behaviour, energy storage and general spring terminology.
Spring Materials Spring material properties, strength and material selection.
Helical Springs Compression and extension spring geometry, rate, stress and deflection.
Torsion Springs Helical torsion spring torque, angular deflection and bending stress.
Disc Springs Disc spring force, deflection, stress and series/parallel stacking.
Leaf Springs Leaf-spring bending stress, deflection and spring-rate calculations.
Spiral / Clock Springs Spiral spring torque, angular deflection, strip length and bending stress.
Fatigue in Springs Mean and alternating stress, endurance, finite-life assessment and fatigue criteria.
Spring Stability and Buckling Compression-spring slenderness, critical deflection, end conditions and buckling.
Spring Surge and Natural Frequency Spring-mass natural frequency, spring surge, vibration modes and dynamic spring behaviour.
Remember: A successful spring design must satisfy more than the required load. The spring must provide the required force or torque throughout its working movement while remaining within acceptable stress, fatigue, stability, temperature, environmental and dimensional limits.